Book & Film: The Hunger Games - Part 3: MOCKINGJAY

Mockingjay comparison

Read Part 1 - The Hunger Games here!

Read Part 2 - Catching Fire here!

Hello and welcome to the third installment of this series where I’m covering the entirety of the Hunger Games in preparation for SUNRISE ON THE REAPING (2026). Mockingjay is not like other books. She’s not only the shortest, but was broken up and made into two movies. Whether or not MOCKINJAY (2014/2015) should have been split is a point of contention for a lot of Hunger Games fans. Personally, I’m grateful because the story is incredibly dense and in order to convey all of the important themes that have been built up in earlier parts of the series, they were going to need a lot of time. That all being said (or rather, typed), I can’t believe we’re at the end of the OG series!


1. Change Your POV, MOCKINGJAY, Change It Around!

I’ve mentioned in an earlier list (check those out if you haven’t yet for some reason) that I resent the fact that the movies took the audience out of Katniss’s perspective and showed us what was happening that contextualized her story. I stand firmly behind that belief when it comes to the first two movies, but I will say the MOCKINGJAY films are made better because the viewer can see what all is happening between District 13 and the Capitol. I especially appreciate getting to see the rescue mission or Peeta happen alongside Finnick’s livestream calling out Snow’s abuse and homicidal tendencies.

MOCKINGJAY PART 2 (2015) Elizabeth Banks and Jennifer Lawrence

2. Effie, My Problematic Fave

Whoever made the decision to have Effie brought along to District 13 in the movies… I am indebted to you for the rest of my life. She’s my favorite side character by far (not including Mr. Abernathy who I am going to officially consider a main character since he’s got his own book) and to have her vanish for the majority of the novel was sick and twisted of Collins. That being said (and some of my readers may know what I’m about to bring up), I think Effie should have been imprisoned in 13 the way Katniss’s glam team was in the novel. I mean there’s no way she would have complied with all of the rules in 13, she would’ve absolutely been hoarding supplies and arguing with the people in charge about her schedule.


3. Haymitch and Katniss Should’ve Gotten the Chance to Work it Out on the Remix

They broke this movie up into two parts and yet I am still greedy enough to be upset that Katniss and Haymitch don’t argue more over Peeta. To be more specific, I wish we would’ve gotten that deleted scene where Haymitch tells Katniss to get all her anger with him out of her system so they can focus on saving Peeta. I could pretend that I have very Important and Practical reasons for wanting this scene to have been included, but the reality is I love these three knuckleheads and the relationship they all have with one another. Also, something that isn’t in either the book or movies is the conversation Haymitch and Peeta have about him being left in the area. I’d sell a kidney for that dialogue.

4. The Cement is Greyer on the Other Side

There aren’t many precautions taken to try and hide the imperfections of District 13 in either versions of Mockingjay. Katniss finding Peeta strapped down and alone in the viewing room after he almost takes her out with his bare hands is some truly haunting imagery. It’s even worse to think about when you remember that they could have sedated him but didn’t for reasons that are never explained.

MOCKINGJAY PART 1 (2014) cast

5. Gale is a Professional Loser

I’m not ashamed to admit that I’ve always been a Gale hater. If that fictional man has no enemies, then I am dead. Funny enough, I don’t even care that he’s forgotten who the real enemy is. I just can’t take how he never stands on business. When Katniss questions why Beetee and Gale are designing a bomb that definitely breaks the Geneva Convention, he responds by throwing Peeta’s torture in Katniss’s face. However, when he’s confronted again after the death of Prim and just about every Capitol child, he insists that it doesn’t even matter which side is responsible for the bombing. The thing is it doesn’t matter who’s responsible in the sense that Coin’s regime was no better than Snow’s, but it pisses me off that the man who is objectively responsible for that particular bombing is trying to throw stones and hide his hands.

6. Where are the 900ish Survivors from 12 in 13

Crazy how the movie doesn’t show Katniss interacting much (if at all) with the survivors of District 12. That’s her community, her people, but I guess the girl was too booked and busy to be congregating when the cameras weren’t rolling. Also, there’s nowhere else to put this, but I love that Greasy Sae is Katniss’s caretaker in the novel after she’s exiled to District 12. I think the movie has this tunnel vision when it comes to what motivates Katniss, like all she cares about is Prim and Peeta, and leaving out the folks from 12 was the natural byproduct of that framing.

7. Katniss… Girl, What Are You Doing Here?

Do I appreciate getting to see Johanna and Katniss get closer as they train to become soldiers in the novel? Absolutely. Those two ladies would have been best friends in another lifetime. Although, I fear it makes more sense for Katniss to have snuck her way into combat (bonus points for the imagery of her coming on a hovercraft carrying medical supplies rather than weapons). It also gives the audience a clear moment they can look back on when figuring out the exact moment Coin decided Katniss was better off dead than alive.

8. Plutarch and Coin are Two Sides of the Same… Well, Coin

The movies and novel like to mix up which of those two bozos are to blame for different decisions that are made. An example of this would be when (example). It’s interesting reading and watching both versions of Mockingjay because it feels like both are using one another to tell the audience that these two people are more alike than not. The biggest difference is Plutarch knows that he can maximize his influence on society and his own safety so long as he’s not in front of the cameras.

9. Killer Katniss Everdeen

We all know the sewers sequence, the mutts, Finnick’s death, the literal death ray that completely disintegrates Messalla, but what movie-watchers don’t know is that Katniss actually murders an innocent woman in her home after she escapes the underground with the remaining members of the Star Squad. It happens so quickly and it’s one of the most jaw-dropping moments in the entire series, which is saying a lot. I hate that MOCKINGJAY PART 2 takes this from us, it actually makes me mad if I think about it too much. Katniss is supposed to get swept up into the war, she’s meant to become part of the war machine she resents so much. It’s how the narrative tracks Katniss’s progress throughout the series. It would have been hard for us to see the girl on fire shoot an unarmed woman, but that is the point.


10. Bitchy Bitchy Haymitchy

I’m letting y’all know now this point and the next will also be about details from the novel that I wish were included in the movie. In the days leading up to Snow’s execution date Katniss is a deeply broken individual who barely even gets up. When she finally does get the courage to reach out to the only person near her that she has any kind of relationship with, Haymitch proceeds to make fun of her for having “boy troubles” which, shocker, is the last thing you want to bring up to a deeply traumatized teenage girl. Katniss is obviously shattered by this and hides in a closet until she sobs herself to sleep.

11. Katniss’s 76th Near Death Experience

In the novel, you get to read about Katniss’s unconscious state after she gets blown sky high in front of Snow’s mansion. It’s an interesting sequence that would have translated phenomenally in a visual format. I know it seems like I’m fiending to watch Katniss suffer in as many ways as possible, but I really do believe some of the best scenes are when the audience gets to see the psychological ramifications of everything Katniss has gone through.

12. Haymitch and His Golden Geese

If you know, you know, and if you don’t… just wait for SUNRISE ON THE REAPING (2026). In all seriousness, I love that HayHay gets his own kind of happy ending (even if it is incredibly bittersweet). Not to get emotional, but after finishing the entire series as an adult, I couldn’t stop thinking about how Haymitch is most certainly going to die before he gets to grow old. I don’t mean to end on such a sad note, it’s actually ironic considering how hopeful the original trilogy ends, but in my defense the last two installments of the Hunger Games takes us back to the Bad Times.


Y’all we done did it, we’ve covered the three OGs of this series. We’re not done just yet, though! We still have to traverse into the mind of Coriolanous Snow (boo) and Haymitch Abernathy (yay). I hope to see everyone next week even though I know a lot of people can’t stand THE BALLAD OF SONGBIRDS AND SNAKES (2023) because Coryo is such an irritating main character to follow. Lucky for me, I am a sucker for a villain’s origin story. As always, may the odds be ever in your favor.

Olivia McGreevy

A simple hobbyist whose time is spent learning everything about their interests no matter how niche. You can find them forcing their opinion onto the masses on Twitter @olivichii.

Next
Next

Book & Film: The Hunger Games — Part 2: CATCHING FIRE