THE ICE PIRATES (1984)

For every move there is a counter. Each attack has a defense. Within the confines of this digital dojo we defend underloved works of art. It has been said that all art will eventually find its audience. We are that audience. Bow to your media. Bow to your device. Choose your fighter.

THE ICE PIRATES (1984) cast

Star Trek (1966-1969) creator Gene Roddenberry is sat in a swivel chair donning a scowl and an ill-fitting Starfleet captain’s uniform. “Screen on, Lt. D.C. Fontana, and activate the next record from the historical database.”

“But Gene…” veteran Star Trek writer Dorothy C. Fontana responds with an exasperated sigh but is cut off by the overly loud and suggestive clearing of Gene Roddenberry’s throat. “But captain…” She corrects herself with no shortage of snark. “Haven’t we seen enough of these STAR WARS (1977) clones? Why don’t we just do what we’ve always done and boldly go where no man has gone before?”

“Oh, Lt. Don’t you see we must be well versed in the visual language and cinematic conventions of these paltry products of popcorn pulp science fiction when crafting our own vision for an idyllic intergalactic utopia? Now screen on for the next serving of space schlock!” Dorothy rolls her eyes and retrieves the next VHS tape. Writer/producer Maurice Hurley rushes over to her and runs the tape over to the television and VCR adorned with cardboard set pieces to make Gene’s garage look like a school play production of the bridge of the USS Enterprise. “What’s the name of this archival offering, Helmsman Hurley?” Gene inquires dismissively.

“THE ICE PIRATES (1984), captain.” Cue the soaring high melody of Jerry Goldsmith’s composed orchestral theme for Star Trek: The Next Generation (1987-1994).

IMDb: 5.7 out of 10

Rotten Tomatoes: 17% Tomatometer / 50% Popcornmeter out of 100%

Metacritic: 44  / 100 Metascore, 5.3 / 10 User Score

Letterboxd: 2.7 out of 5

While the aforementioned cosplay is the conjuring of my conjecture, it is true that Roddenberry screened a smattering of sci-fi de jour for cautionary inspiration when developing Star Trek:The Next Generation. Naturally, he applauded celebrated works of the era such as BLADE RUNNER (1982) and ALIENS (1986) but he also had some particularly prickly opinions on Stewart Raffill’s space swashbuckling epic, THE ICE PIRATES! THE ICE PIRATES tells the sensitive story of a ragtag group of space pirates risking life, limb, and castration to heist ice in a galaxy devoid of stable fresh water source until they learn the location of a mythical planet that has water in abundance! In other words, a chilling glimpse into our eventual thirsty testicleless existence should we continue to give data centers carte blanche.

THE ICE PIRATES (1984)

Originally greenlit by Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Studios as a serious science fiction feature with a sizable $20 million budget. The production and original script intended to be a STAR WARS styled serious space saga in a similar size and scope but after a disastrous start to the decade, due mostly to extravagant investments into a Las Vegas hotel and casino, MGM slashed the budget to $8 million. Undeterred and well-versed in stretching budgetary constraints, director Stewart Raffill opted for a comedic rewrite on screenwriter Stanford Sherman’s, of KRULL (1983) fame, script with an escapade emphasizing campy character work over starfaring action set pieces.

Raffill impressed MGM brass with his previous feature HIGH RISK (1981), a low-budget heist film that came in on time, under budget, and performed competently despite a limited theatrical release. In retooling Sherman’s original dark, high-concept, sci-fi screenplay Raffill took a lot of inspiration from THE CRIMSON PIRATE (1952), a Technicolor tinted comedic swashbuckler directed by Robert Siodmak and starring Burt Lancaster, and with the assistance with some studio bigwig connections assembled a crackerjack cast.

THE ICE PIRATES (1984) movie poster

The Lazarus Man (1996) himself, Robert Urich would star as our wisecracking charismatic captain Jason. With him as always is his right hand man Roscoe played by Michael D. Roberts of Manimal (1983) fame. Spurring the quest and acting as a love interest is Princess Karina portrayed by Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Television frequent flyer and daughter to dulcet toned bass-baritone crooner Bing Crosby, Mary Crosby. Then we’ve got our pirate supporting players of Maida, Killjoy, and Zeno performed by Hollywood royalty Anjelica Huston, gridiron goliath and future Goonie John Matuszak, and everyone’s favorite HELLBOY (2004) Ron Pearlman respectively. The film also features a significant role for “master gagsmith” Bruce Vilanche as compulsive gambler Wendon in addition to an uncredited script doctor role to punch up jokes. If that wasn’t enough Hollywood walk of fame street cred for you, this flick also features one of the final roles for John Carradine as Supreme Commander.

At this point you might be asking “Hey, Vito. If this cast is so great then how come ‘The Great Bird Of The Galaxy’ (nickname for Gene Roddenberry, don’t ask me) didn’t like it and it only grossed a $14 million box office against its $8 million dollar budget?” Well to that I can only respond with “You a cop?” There’s a whole bunch of reasons! I’m not too busy right now so I’ll articulate a few of them if you care to read on.

There was beef behind the scenes and we’re not talking about "Mrs. O'Leary's Cow.” When THE ICE PIRATES was given the green light it was under the auspices of MGM chief David Begelman and producer John Foreman. During preproduction Begelman was removed and replaced by Frank Yablans who had some kind of personal conflict with Foreman over soon-to-be salad dressing magnate Paul Newman. I presume the rationale was that if THE ICE PIRATES failed it would reflect poorly on Foreman so the feud got transferred to Raffil as that project’s director. Yablans cancelled funding, halted work orders mid-construction, spoiled a very significant plot twist in the trailer, cut the ending from the theatrical release without notifying Raffill, and even went as far as trashing the motion picture in the press calling it “unreleasable” upon its release.

The push and pull backstage is reflected in the final product. Tightened pursestrings from the studio required props and sets to be obviously recycled from LOGAN’S RUN (1977) rather than made custom for this production. The costume body armor Anjelica Huston wears as Maida during the bar scene was reused from THE SWORD AND THE SORCERER (1982). It even has ROLLERBALL (1975) playing on television screens in a control room and has sight gag parodies of THE ROAD WARRIOR (1981). Also, one can’t help but question the efficacy of chainmail in space when costuming the villainous H2O hoarding Templars of Mithra. While I find the sword/sorcery/swashbuckling/space aesthetic and visual language here charming and always celebrate the EPA Waste Management Guide’s Three R’s of reduce, reuse, and recycle, critics and audiences deride the appearance of the THE ICE PIRATES as cheesy and cheap (and don’t think we don’t take note of whose Park Avenue parents didn’t make them wear hand-me-downs).

That kind of reception speaks to the largest issue at work here: the space opera bubble had burst. If you look at the hit films of 1984 (which was a red-letter year for American cinema) you’ve got THE ICE PIRATES duking it out with the likes of THE KARATE KID, GHOSTBUSTERS, GREMLINS, THE TERMINATOR, BEVERLY HILLS COP, AMADEUS, FOOTLOOSE, and INDIANA JONES AND THE TEMPLE OF DOOM just to name a few. After a slew of space movies (including three STAR WARS and a couple of STAR TREKS) audiences found themselves burned out like a stellar remnant for the genre. The pendulous pull of motion picture preferences had plummeted to terra firma thrills over cinematic sensations amongst the stars for the time being.

Despite all this THE ICE PIRATES is still a fun foray into sci-fi fantasy. It’s original and while the humor can be sophomoric at times, the flick is quirkily quotable and still good for a cheeky cosmic corsair chuckle. True to the poster art it’s “a totally spaced adventure” with some scenes sticking with me like a raging case of space herpes! If nothing else, it proved that the cinematic subdivision of space opera was nearly ripe for lampooning but still a bit premature. This materialization would not be consummated by MGM Studios until June 24, 1987 with the release of the epitome of STAR WARS spoofing cinema, Mel Brooks’ SPACEBALLS.

THE ICE PIRATES (1984) Robert Urich

“Damn it, Bones!” Gene Roddenberry frantically grabs a nearby trashcan and proceeds to violently vomit. He exclaims “That was the worst one yet!” in between exaggerated bouts of hacking and groaning. “I don’t mean to be hyperbolic but this farce should be singularly responsible for bringing back the death penalty to California for crimes against science fiction!”

Fontana knows Gene well enough to sense there’s more than meets the eye from his vaudevillian vituperation. “Come on Gene… er… um… captain. It wasn’t that bad. We’ve watched way worse. What about this film has got you so upset?”

Roddenberry wipes the spittle from his quivering lip and looks back to the closing credits crossing the screen with an increased intensity. His gaze focuses on a name: Hairdresser…………………Candida R. Conery. Gene’s eyes narrow, face reddens, and veins bulge in forehead and neck as he screams “KHAN-ERY!”

Vito Nusret

If Vito isn't in his basement watching movies or pro wrestling with his two rowdy dogs he's probably in a lot of trouble and needs help so be ready to alert the authorities.

Next
Next

CLIFFORD (1994)